Here's a more toned-down, albeit, "balanced" reaction to the bill:
http://sharonastyk.com/2009/03/14/why-im-not-panicking-about-hr-875/
Here's some excerpts:
The rhetoric has been overblown to a destructive degree. As Tom Philpott points out at Grist:
Ive been reading hysterical missives about H.R. 875 for weeks. I could never square them with the text of the bill, which is admittedly vague. For example, the bill seeks to regulate any food production facility which it defines as any farm, ranch, orchard, vineyard, aquaculture facility, or confined animal-feeding operation.
But then again, the USDA already regulates farms. And 24 hours GPS tracking of
animals? Not in there. Warrentless government entry to farms? Cant find it.
More recently, reading around the web, I found more reasoned takes on H.R. 875. The bill may not be worth supporting and from what I hear, it has little chance of passing. But it hardly represents the end of farming, much less the end of organic farming. The Organic Consumers Association, an energetic food-industry watchdog, recently called the paranoia around H.R. 875 the Internet rumor of the week.
The Organic Consumers Association has this to say:
The Organic Consumers Association is not taking a position for or against this bill, but encouraging its members to write to Congress to urge it to enact food safety legislation that addresses the inherent dangers of our industrialized food system without burdening certified organic and farm-to-consumer operations.
Quite sensibly, the OCA wants Congress to avoid one-size-fits-all legislation. Regulations that make sense for a 1000-acre spinach farm could push a diversified operation that includes spinach in its crop mix out of business. Sustainable-food advocates should oppose H.R. 875 until it adds scale-appropriate language.
But effective opposition does not mean indulging in fictional rants about it. Theres no evidence that the bill aims to end farming; insisting that it does destroys credibility.
click on the link above for complete article....