Citrus Growers Forum Index Citrus Growers Forum

This is the read-only version of the Citrus Growers Forum.

Breaking news: the Citrus Growers Forum is reborn from its ashes!

Citrus Growers v2.0

STARFRUIT - warning to kidney patients

 
Citrus Growers Forum Index du Forum -> Fruit & Tropicals other than citrus
Author Message
Patty_in_wisc
Citrus Angel


Joined: 15 Nov 2005
Posts: 1842
Location: zone 5 Milwaukee, Wi

Posted: Tue 14 Oct, 2008 6:01 pm

I saw this in a email & thought I'd share.

Growers defensive as doctor raises starfruit danger

KUALA LUMPUR, MALAYSIA: Starfruit (also known as carambola)
can be life-threatening to people with kidney problems.

Professor Dr Tan Si Yen, a medical specialist at the
University Malaya Medical Centre, said the fruit contains a
neurotoxin and a high level of oxalic acid (or oxalate) which
could be harmful to renal patients.

Dr Tan was referring to retiree Tang Gon Seang, who allegedly
slipped into a coma after eating starfruit in China.

Dr Tan said the weakened kidneys of renal patients were not
able to process the high level of oxalate, causing the organ
to fail.

Speaking at the MCA Public Service and Complaints Bureau
yesterday, he said typical symptoms occurred within one to
five hours.

They include persistent hiccups, nausea, vomiting, agitation,
insomnia, mental confusion and convulsions.

"It can also cause death but it can be treated through
aggressive dialysis sessions," said Dr Tan, adding that no
deaths had been recorded so far.

He stressed that starfruit poisoning only occurred if some
degree of kidney failure already existed.

"In Tang's case, he was already having kidney problems and
when he consumed the starfruit, he could not process the
neurotoxin and oxalic acid, causing him to go into a coma."

Dr Tan said as little as half of a fruit or less than eight
ounces of juice could cause serious symptoms in a kidney
patient.

The only medical treatment for starfruit intoxication is
prompt kidney dialysis.

He said researchers in Brazil and Taiwan were studying how
starfruit causes serious life-threatening reactions in kidney
patients.

Meanwhile, starfruit growers in the country denied that the
fruit could be a health hazard to kidney patients.

Chairman of the Malaysian Fruit Exporter Association and a
starfruit grower, Ricky Yong, said it was not fair for any
party to make allegations about starfruit.

"Proper studies have yet to be conducted," he said.

Yong said other factors such as pesticides and agricultural
practices could also be a cause for Tang's condition.

Another starfruit grower, Kit Chan, shared Yong's sentiments.

He said without a proper announcement by the Agriculture
Department, it was not fair to make allegations about the ill
effects of eating starfruit.

"No science journal has come out with any such statement about
the fruit."

__._,_.___

_________________
Patty
I drink wine to make other people more interesting Wink
Back to top
JoeReal
Site Admin
Site Admin


Joined: 16 Nov 2005
Posts: 4726
Location: Davis, California

Posted: Tue 14 Oct, 2008 7:12 pm

Thanks Patty, that would be a nice addition to the article that I posted more than a year ago. Feel free to redistribute better information from this old thread:

link
Back to top
Patty_in_wisc
Citrus Angel


Joined: 15 Nov 2005
Posts: 1842
Location: zone 5 Milwaukee, Wi

Posted: Tue 14 Oct, 2008 7:31 pm

Thanks Joe. Last year I wasn't on here much so I missed your post on this. I just heard of it, so to me it's new Embarassed

_________________
Patty
I drink wine to make other people more interesting Wink
Back to top
JoeReal
Site Admin
Site Admin


Joined: 16 Nov 2005
Posts: 4726
Location: Davis, California

Posted: Tue 14 Oct, 2008 7:44 pm

I planned of making Star Fruit wine, so this topic I can't forget. Last 2007, in one of the regional fairs in Australia, the Star Fruit Wine garnered best of show. But when I read the news and have confirmed this with pubmed, our very credible medical and scientific journal, I dropped the plans of making star fruit wine. I don't want to be blamed for the death of someone drinking such wine. Older people are prone to suffering from some type of kidney problems, and so are the most susceptible group, but they are the group that most appreciates wine if they are still allowed by their doctors to drink.

So my kids and I just converted them to juice and enjoyed them as such.
Back to top
Citrus Growers Forum Index du Forum -> Fruit & Tropicals other than citrus
Page 1 of 1
Informations
Qui est en ligne ? Our users have posted a total of 66068 messages
We have 3235 registered members on this websites
Most users ever online was 70 on Tue 30 Oct, 2012 10:12 am

Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group